A fireside chat with ChatGPT about cottaging in Canada

Ever since ChatGPT, an advanced chatbot created by OpenAI, was released to the public in November 2022, it has taken the internet by storm; disrupting academia and content creation with its ability to generate essays and SEO optimized blogs in a conversational tone. Before it became a paid tool, I sat down with ChatGPT for an interview on cottaging in Canada. While it wasn’t afraid to weigh in on where the best butter tarts can be found in Ontario—a controversial question for our readers who are passionate butter tart connoisseurs. (We like to think our story about the best butter tarts in Ontario is a more exhaustive list. You can read it here). Despite my probing, it was reluctant to offer up personal opinions or preferences and prefaced answers to questions of that nature with a disclaimer that it is only a language model.

While ChatGPT may have been trained using text databases from the internet, some of its answers included noticeable factual inaccuracies. When I asked it to rank the best Great Lakes for waterskiing, it incorrectly identified Lake St. Clair as a Great Lake. In a FAQ posted on ChatGPT’s website, it acknowledges that it is not connected to the internet and will produce incorrect answers on occasion. “It has limited knowledge of the world and events after 2021 and may also occasionally produce harmful instructions or biased content.”

Note: This interview has been left unedited and incorrect information has been explained in italics below the answer.


Q: Where is your favourite place to cottage in Canada?

A: As a language model, I don’t have personal preferences or experiences. However, Canada is known for its beautiful natural landscapes, and many people enjoy cottaging in locations such as Muskoka, Haliburton, and the Kawarthas in Ontario, the Laurentians in Quebec, and the Okanagan Valley in British Columbia. Each of these regions offer unique features and attractions such as lakes, forests, and mountains.

Q: What lake in Ontario has the most beautiful sunsets?

A: Different people have different opinions about what makes a sunset beautiful, but many people find that sunsets over lakes can be particularly stunning. In Ontario, there are many lakes known for their beautiful sunsets, including Lake Superior, Lake Huron, Lake Ontario, and Lake Erie. Some of the most popular lakes for sunsets in Ontario include Muskoka Lakes, Lake of Bays, and Georgian Bay. These lakes offer a variety of vantage points from which to view the sunset, such as boat cruises, waterfront cottages, and public parks.

Fact check: Muskoka Lakes is a municipality, and there are several lakes that reside within it. 

Q: Rank the Great Lakes in order of the best for waterskiing

A: The Great Lakes are known for their recreational opportunities, including waterskiing. However, the best lake for waterskiing would depend on factors such as the size of the lake, the quality of the water, the weather conditions, and the presence of ski clubs or other facilities. Here is a list of Great Lakes in order of popularity for waterskiing:

  1. Lake St. Clair: It is the smallest of the Great Lakes and has the warmest water. It is known to have great waves and flat water ideal for slalom skiing and barefoot skiing.
  2. Lake Huron: It has the longest shoreline of the Great Lakes and offers a variety of water conditions, from calm bays to large swells.
  3. Lake Michigan: It is known for its consistent wind, which can create excellent conditions for jumping and slalom skiing.
  4. Lake Erie: It is the warmest and shallowest of the Great Lakes, making it ideal for beginners and recreational skiers.
  5. Lake Superior: It is the largest and coldest of the Great Lakes, it is known for its beautiful scenery, but the water can be quite choppy and the wind can be strong, making it less ideal for waterskiing.
  6. Lake Ontario: It is the easternmost of the Great Lakes and the smallest in surface area, it is known for its relatively calm waters, making it a good place for recreational waterskiing, but the water can be colder than the other lakes.

Please note that this is not a definitive ranking and other factors such as personal preference and skill level also play a role in determining the best lake for waterskiing.

Fact check: Lake St. Clair is not one of the Great Lakes. The Great Lakes consist of Huron, Ontario, Erie, Superior, and Michigan.

Q: How would you define a cottage?

A: A cottage is typically defined as a small, simple, and usually old-fashioned vacation home or second home, typically located in a rural or semi-rural area such as near a lake or beach. Cottages are often used as summer homes or for weekend getaways. They are typically smaller than a primary residence and often have a rustic or cozy feel. Some cottages may have basic amenities such as a kitchen and bathroom, while others may be more rustic with outdoor facilities. Cottages may be owned or rented, and can be found in many different locations, such as in the countryside, by a lake, or on a beach.

Q: Where are the best butter tarts in Ontario?

A: Butter tarts are a popular treat in Ontario, Canada, and are known for their flaky pastry crust and gooey, sweet filling. The best butter tarts can be found in many places across the province, but some of the most popular locations include:

  1. Kawartha Dairy in Bobcaygeon, Ontario – They are famous for their butter tarts and are known to have the best butter tarts in Ontario.
  2. The Butter Tart Factory in Midland, Ontario – They have a wide variety of butter tarts, including traditional, pecan, raisin, chocolate, and more.
  3. Golden Harvest in Cambridge, Ontario – They offer homemade butter tarts using locally sourced ingredients.
  4. The Little Red Kitchen Bakery in Fenelon Falls, Ontario – They are known for their traditional butter tarts, and also offer unique flavors such as maple bacon and salted caramel.
  5. The Tart Lady in Toronto, Ontario – They offer a variety of flavors in their butter tarts, which are all made with real butter and locally sourced ingredients.

Please note that this is not a definitive list and there are many other bakeries and small businesses across Ontario that offer delicious butter tarts.

Fact check: Kawartha Dairy does not make their own butter tarts; they bring them in from Don’s Bakery. There is no Butter Tart Factory in Midland, Ont., however there is a butter tart festival. There is also no Golden Harvest bakery in Cambridge, however there is a Golden Hearth Bakery in Kitchener, Ont. According to their website, they don’t sell butter tarts. No bakery exists in Fenelon Falls under the name The Little Red Kitchen Bakery, however there is a Little Pie Shack, and they do sell butter tarts. I could find no record of a business in Toronto called The Tart Lady. However, there is a business called The Butter Tart Lady that is located in Manitoba.

Q: What is the best thing about cottaging in Canada?

A: Cottaging in Canada can be a wonderful experience due to the country’s beautiful natural landscapes and varied recreational opportunities. Some of the best things about cottaging in Canada include:

  1. Scenic beauty: Canada is known for its beautiful natural landscapes, including lakes, forests, and mountains. Cottaging in Canada allows you to enjoy the beauty of nature, with many cottages located in picturesque settings such as on the shore of a lake or in the heart of a forest.
  2. Recreational activities: Cottages are often located in areas where there are many recreational activities to enjoy, such as swimming, boating, fishing, hiking, and skiing.
  3. Relaxation: Being away from the hustle and bustle of city life and enjoying the peace and quiet of the countryside can be a great way to relax and unwind.
  4. Family and social activities: Cottages are often used as a gathering place for families and friends and provide opportunities for socializing, playing games, and enjoying meals together.
  5. Affordable vacation: Cottages are often more affordable than hotels, which makes it a budget-friendly vacation option.
  6. Building memories: Cottage trips are often connected to fond memories of spending time with loved ones, enjoying the outdoors, and creating lasting memories.

Please note that this is not an exhaustive list and other factors such as personal preference, location, time of year and the weather may come into play when considering the best things about cottaging in Canada.

Feature Video