My kitchen came from a Habitat for Humanity ReStore. So did some lighting, the sink, and the faucet. Most of the tools I built it with? Facebook Marketplace. I’ve been sourcing this way for years—at this point, it’s a reflex—but the process still takes patience, persistence, and vision. You won’t walk into a ReStore and find exactly what you need. Instead, you build a flexible mental image, then check in regularly—sometimes over months—until the right pieces appear.
But it’s worth it. I paid $1,500 for cabinets that would have cost more than $6,000 new. Used kitchen cabinets are surprisingly reusable, even when mixed from different sources, because they’re standardized: base units are almost always 34.” tall and 24” deep, with consistent widths (for uppers too) of 18, 24, 30, and 36 inches. It’s completely workable to mix and match from different manufacturers; it’s not like you’re hunting for unicorns. You should, however, commit to a painted finish. It’s the only practical way to unify old and new, different woods, and mismatched substrates. And you’ll likely have to buy or build a few cabinets to fill gaps. I combined dark wood island units, white painted bases, and shop-built raw wood pieces. Paint ties it all together.
First, homework
Walking into a ReStore unprepared is a good way to miss the right kitchen or buy the wrong one. Start with a rough layout, but not a detailed plan—will your kitchen be a galley or a U-shape? How many corners, windows, and doors? Sketch it on graph paper, with measurements of the space. I taped out my layout on the floor and walls and walked through frying imaginary eggs, washing imaginary dishes, gazing out of imaginary windows—before I went shopping.
If plumbing or electrical needs to move, get quotes first and design around what’s practical—and then buy cabinets to fit the layout, not the reverse. Plan for transport and storage as well. The right kitchen may appear before you’re ready to install it. I rented a storage unit for a couple of months. I also visited a few kitchen showrooms to see layouts at full scale. This helped clarify what my layout needed.
What’s in store
When you’re looking, pay attention to the base cabinets—specifically the corners, which define everything else. Lazy Susan corner cabinets with articulated doors are expensive new, so finding them used is a genuine score. Finding all the upper cabinets you need matters less; these simple boxes are easier to reconfigure or build.
Drawer units are another great find, especially when a 36“ , three-drawer base can cost $500+ new. My set included two drawer units, and nobody ever regrets extra drawers. The same goes for expensive, specialty pieces like pull-out spice racks or waste inserts. Grab them.
Choose a simple door style, but ignore the hardware. Shaker-style doors are easy to match; ornate raised panels are not. Knobs and pulls are irrelevant—they can be replaced, and even the holes can be filled (Bondo works) and painted over. Hinges and drawer slides matter more, so you should test, open, and close everything. Good, soft-close hardware suggests the cabinets themselves are high quality. (Blum is the gold standard.) But even stiff, broken hardware is replaceable if the cabinet boxes are sound.
Plywood boxes are preferable, but 5 /8” particleboard is common and it’s not a dealbreaker. Check for screwed and glued corners. Staples alone on the corners mean the cabinets were made more cheaply. Give each cabinet a gentle nudge: it shouldn’t wobble much (though loose joints can be reinforced with screws and corner blocks). And don’t worry if there are some pieces you won’t use. My set came with a weird angled corner, a wine rack, and a tall pantry unit that didn’t fit in my kitchen. The pantry is now workshop storage. Buy the lot to get the key pieces you need. Extra cabinets can always be broken down for material to build infills and other projects.
The setup
Before installation, lay out the cabinets on the floor and spend some time with the arrangement. Gaps and awkward spots will become obvious. I added a 6” filler beside the dishwasher for more standing room—something that didn’t show up on paper—and I built a 10” cabinet to mirror a spice unit and keep the layout balanced. Our kitchen also has two 2” filler strips flanking the sink. When you’re adapting a used kitchen, you’ll inevitably need to work with cabinet runs that don’t quite fill your space.
Painting comes down to three options: brushing (simplest, but less smooth), DIY spraying (excellent results, but a big job—I had to build a temporary booth where I sprayed all 37 doors), or hiring a pro for the best finish. Pros can also use tougher commercial coatings.
Don’t cut corners on countertops or hardware. They make the kitchen feel cohesive, rather than a collection of salvaged parts. Our mix-and-match cabinets disappear under a slab of leathered granite. (A used countertop will be almost impossible to fit well in your kitchen. Avoid.) Swapping the dated, ’90s stainless pulls for antiqued pewter ones jumped the kitchen forward by decades. Before ordering, I printed images of them at actual size, cut them out and taped them to the cabinets. Laser prints make a surprisingly convincing preview.
Bottom line
The ReStore cabinets cost $1,500. A comparable set from RTI Cabinets would cost more than $6,000 before tax. Ikea may be cheaper (about 25 per cent less than RTI), but the Swedes offer fewer size options. Adding countertops, appliances, paint, and fixtures raised our total cost, but it’s still a fraction of a new custom kitchen.
In hindsight, I should have planned for the granite counter earlier and more carefully—a slightly adjusted layout would have needed only one slab of expensive granite, not two. That, and next time I’ll hire out the spray painting.
This article was originally published in the Early Summer ’26 issue of Cottage Life.
Related Story DIYer mistakes that even the experts make
Related Story Have you heard of online DIY coaching?
Related Story 6 upgrades for your dream cottage kitchen